What can brands learn from the Bake Off?
This article first appeared in the September 2026 issue of Dorset Life.
You need all the right ingredients? You should spend more time in a tent? That there’s no greater accolade than a Hollywood Handshake? Perhaps. But there’s a simpler lesson hiding in plain sight: consistency is king.
The judges can't stop talking about consistency. Not only do you need to know the difference between stiff peaks and the ribbon stage(!), but when the champion baker finally hoists the hallowed cake stand, they'll have demonstrated consistency not just across the series, but within individual challenges too.
There’s a reason contestants are challenged to bake identical cakes rather than simply being told to “whip up a batch of something nice”. Most of us can produce one excellent cupcake on a good day. Producing a dozen that look, taste and feel exactly the same is another matter entirely. That ability to deliver the same result time and time again is what elevates someone from enthusiastic amateur to trusted expert.
The same principle applies to business. Consistency matters not only in the products and services you provide, but in the way you communicate. When every touchpoint feels connected, trust grows. Each interaction helps customers know what to expect and to feel confident recommending you to others.
One organisation we worked with had lots of departments communicating with customers independently. Every team was doing a good job, but each had developed its own way of speaking. When we stepped back and looked at the customer experience as a whole, it felt less like one organisation and more like several different businesses sharing the same logo.
What they hadn’t considered was the halo effect of consistency. By creating a clearer brand and a shared approach to communication, every part of the organisation benefited. Customers became more aware of the full range of services available. Teams started reinforcing one another rather than operating in isolation. Staff spent less time reinventing the wheel and more time focusing on the work that mattered.
That’s the hidden cost of inconsistency. It’s the time spent solving avoidable problems, recreating assets, answering the same questions and making decisions from scratch.
People often see brand guidelines, systems and processes as restrictive. In reality, the best ones do the opposite. They remove uncertainty, speed up decision-making and make life easier. Consistency doesn’t mean becoming robotic or forcing everyone to speak from the same script. It means creating a shared understanding of who you are, what you stand for and how that should be reflected across the organisation.
A quick test? Ask ten customers to describe your business. If their answers sound remarkably similar, you’re probably on the right track. If they vary wildly, you may have created more of an Eton Mess than a showstopper.
And if you’re struggling to improve consistency, take inspiration from Bake Off. Get the ingredients right and make sure everyone is working from the same recipe. Failing that, add more icing!
We're always happy to chat about brands, businesses and big ideas. Over the phone is fine, but we much prefer a cup of tea (with cake, of course!).